Big Brother and Mental Health
Wednesday 24th May
It’s interesting - if you keep up with Big Brother you may be aware by now that one of the housemates, Shahbaz Chaudhry, has left the house amid a mental-health kerfuffle.
It was quite clear during the first few days of the programme that he was not strong enough to survive the highly stressful environment he would encounter.
Now the Mental Health Foundation are complaining that he was ever let in. Full story here.
I believe there have been three complaints so far - Shahbaz with his unstable state, Pete with his Tourettes syndrome and a less-substantiated one regarding Nikki and anorexia.
I think these foundations are basically good for looking out for the vulnerable and supporting their interests - however it should be noted that each one of the contestants has put themselves forward for the show, and are free to leave at any time.
There is an element of consent - the contestant has consented to enter the house and have some of their rights taken out of their control. There is an escape - they just say the word and they can leave. On top of that, the housemates are vetted by psychologists before they go in to hopefully ensure they will cope with the situations which will arise.
This is actually quite a lot more welfare care than the harsh world outside will normally afford them, and I think that the producers should not be seen to have failed if they let an unstable person in the house - more that their safeguards, which they don’t have to provide, were not quite as good as they could have been, or were circumvented.
Consider white-water rafting. Sure, you can wear a hard hat and a life jacket, but you’re still throwing yourself down a dangerous river full of rocks in a glorified inner-tube. The individual must accept some responsibility for their actions and decisions.
Oh… and I think Pete is great. A really positive character and he has to be doing good for Tourettes sufferers everwhere. I often hear people express that Tourettes isn’t real, and is just a good excuse to swear. Well, I challenge you to watch him for an hour or two, seeing the amount of energy he expends on his problem, and then say that he’s making it up. It’s quite clear he doesn’t want to be ticking all the time, but fortunately has come to terms with it sufficiently to function in the real (or fake) world.
So far I’ve managed so far to aviod all things Big Brother… then you slipped this in your blog…. Doh!!!
Mr Hedgehog
24 May 06 at 10:52 am
Of course, Shahbaz seemed more interested in taking the ultimate way out. Not sure how you can manage to kill yourself on live television. The ultimate suicide watch.
Sarah
24 May 06 at 10:58 am
I’ve already unashamedly admitted my love for the programme - as a people-watcher it’s the ultimate chance to sit back with a cup of tea and see how (some) humans work.
Anyway… it’ll all be over in three months
I wonder if I can set a ‘big brother filter’… watch this space…
stu
24 May 06 at 11:00 am
As long as you don’t start banging on about the World Cup as well
Rich
24 May 06 at 11:11 am
After pledging not to watch any BB this year I accidentaly managed to watch a whole hour of it on Monday night! I too love people watching, but I just don’t want it to take over my life for the next 3 months, maybe I can just pop in once in a while.
I have to agree with you about Pete, he is great when you get used to the ticks, and it will be good for people with TS.
Kate
24 May 06 at 11:13 am
I can’t stand the program - hate it. Had to sit there watching it last night as the girlfriend wasn’t happy me being in the other room on the computer, so instead i was subjected to BB while playing on the laptop. Not tonight, other room for me or the TV’s off!
Code Monkey
24 May 06 at 11:37 am
Now I almost wish I could watch it too:)
Dakota
24 May 06 at 2:57 pm
Ahhh, it’s big brother mania at work! I don’t need to watch it, I can just take all the aural battering every morning by colleagues dying to tell me what’s happened! LOL
I’m gonna get hooked, I can tell. Grrr
DoGGa
24 May 06 at 8:31 pm